The Music Has To Be Good
The picture loads from YouTube. The player loads only when you press Play. Turn on captions in the player if you need them.
Black Dave MK2 questions the common advice that the song has to be good before marketing starts. He says people can describe good marketing in detail but stay vague on what makes a song good enough, and he wishes early-career artists heard more talk about song quality than about promotion.
Not by We Them Media Channel: Black Dave MK2. Published Wednesday 23 September 2026.
The owner's description puts the music first and calls it step one.
Titles are the owner’s. It plays from their channel.
Watch it on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Transcript
This transcript may contain errors. This video belongs to Black Dave MK2. Letters mark each change of speaker.
These are the speakers’ own words. We have not checked their claims.
0:00 A: I make music. I go by Black Dave Mark II, Black Dave MKII, because there's another Black Dave somewhere in the world who is already using that name and has put out a lot of music. So why not be the evolved version of Black Dave, Black Dave Mark II? Something that I hear a lot when people talk about music marketing, like artist development, like dealing with music artists, It's like, the first thing is the song has to be good. That's always the thing. It's like, the song has to be good. Once the song is good, then we can start doing all this other stuff. I feel like we underemphasize what the song is good actually means, and I feel like we should be spending a lot more time and energy talking about songs and what makes songs good. As opposed to what to do once we have the song. I wonder how many people actually have a song that is worth the promotion as opposed to trying to figure out how to promote the song that may not be worth the promotion. I think that when you look at song quality versus marketing and marketing quality and all that, there is a realm where you You can over-index in the marketing and still make a song that might not be it, it. Turning demos into smashes or whatever. And I've just been thinking a lot about knowing when the song is right. Okay, this song is right. Now I can start to figure everything else out. Is it a group of people? Is there a recording quality standard? Is there a lyrical quality standard? Is there a production standard? It's so interesting how vague that idea is, but we can tell you what good marketing is. And marketing can be just as infinite as the amount of songs, honestly. Obviously there are only so many platforms and methods of deployment, But it's really not that limited. But we have such a strong hold on what marketing works, and we don't have a strong hold on what kind of songs work. Not that songs should work or not work, but I feel like there are ways to say, okay, the song has passed the quality threshold. I'm a big believer that A song only has to be a certain amount of good in order for it to be able to be used for whatever. By the way, my songs are all a certain amount of good, so don't even ask. It's an interesting time, and only becomes more interesting because I feel like it gets easier and easier and easier to make music, even if And this is an extreme example. There have been songs that have come out that people don't realize are fully AI-generated that they think are good songs. And so they have met whatever qualities are required or whatever threshold is required to keep someone's attention, to make them want to listen to it a second time, to make them want to connect with the work or the output, whatever you want to call it. I'm not anti-AI over here, so. It doesn't matter to me what you call it. I don't know what to do with this. It just feels like we don't talk enough about what makes songs good or how to make songs good, especially when it comes to artists who are earlier in their career. Thinking a lot about, man, this is a great direction, even, is super helpful when you're in the beginning. I'm not going to start making content around that. I'm not going to be the guy who advises you about that stuff. It's just a thought. And as always, I'm sharing it. I'll catch you next week.
More from this hub
- Life After AI Takes My Job
- What's In A Name?
- Prepare to Download
- Takedowns
- Lottery Ticket
- Dinner
- Haters
- Glory Days
- Splits
- You Just Had To Be There
- Pick Your Battles
Something wrong, or a video you want off this page? Write to wethem.xyz@gmail.com and it is fixed or taken down within 48 hours.
