The One Question bounty closes Thursday 10 December.

Join in
We Them Media logo We Them Media Support us

Takedowns

The picture loads from YouTube. The player loads only when you press Play. Turn on captions in the player if you need them.

Black Dave MK2 reacts to reports of DistroKid removing music and asks what artists should use if not the big platforms and their changing rules. He thinks about direct downloads, building an app for himself and friends, and concludes that playing regional shows and meeting people in person still works best for many musicians.

Not by We Them Media Channel: Black Dave MK2. Published Wednesday 14 October 2026.

This one is about the recent Distrokid music removals and the questions going unasked after them.

Titles are the owner’s. It plays from their channel.

Transcript

This transcript may contain errors. This video belongs to Black Dave MK2. Letters mark each change of speaker.

These are the speakers’ own words. We have not checked their claims.

0:00 A: It appears that DistroKid has been removing people's music lately for reasons that we are all apparently unsure of, and everyone is upset and thinking, is this a label doing this? Is this a result of so much AI music being uploaded? Is this uncleared samples finally getting caught? Is this one of so, so, so many things? It feels like in this, there are a couple of important conversations not being had. The first one I think about is what should we be doing instead? Is there a music distributor that we should be using instead? Is there a method we should go about making or releasing music that we haven't been considering. In all honesty, uploading to all these platforms really forces us to have to follow their rules, even if they're nonsense, even if they change on a dime. That's just how it is. The other thing I think a lot about, and this is what's really more important to me, is how do I create a world where people can access my music through alternative methods? The obvious thing is having your own place where people can download your music. Folks are not excited about having to download music themselves and add it to their music player of choice themselves. I get it. I remember when Apple Music came out, they started downsizing iPhones. And if you got the smallest iPhone, you're kind of forced into using Apple Music because you couldn't fit music on your phone anymore. And I feel like we've just been experiencing that ripple effect over time, even though the phone sizes are larger. We're now, you know, taking these ridiculously large pictures and 4K videos at 120 frames per second or whatever phones are on now. I don't know if there is a proper method for streaming music alternatively that exists, because it's not like we can connect our things to Spotify or to Apple Music without using a distribution service. I do, however, think that there is a space for people who want to connect with their audience In other ways. Something I've been thinking a lot about lately is making an app for me, or an app for me and my friends, or an app for a music community or something. I've talked a bunch of times about discovery and how discovery through being adjacent to others is really one of the keys, one of the best methods. I think that even looking at social media and that form of discovery, it's another place where we're sort of beholden to the rules that change every day. The algorithm changes every day. I'm sure, you know, Google ads, Facebook ads, Instagram ads, Instagram algo, X and- X. Everything with them. And once you get into that ad system, then they're, you know, only optimizing you once you have ads and all this stuff. People are trying to get into content and they hate making content and they just want to make music. And there's all this stuff. It really is a reminder that There is no better place- currently, one of the best places is to just hit the streets, play some shows, hand out some CDs, shake some hands, kiss some babies. It's interesting how we've moved so far into technology that the only way to find success is to move away from it. As a creative person. And not in the sense of not using technology for your work, but in the sense of using all the new technology to get that work out into the world. Many of us are better off just driving in our region and playing shows and meeting people and doing songs with artists and stuff like that. It's like, man, why do we have all these tools? Why do we have all this tech if we just have to keep doing the thing that we've always been doing? Maybe there's someone out there who's like, oh no, I have the answer to this question, and they make a thing and it's really sick. And if you end up inspired by this video and the thing does actually work, you should call me and let me use it for free so that I can find more success in my journey as well. I guess that's it. That's really what I'm thinking about right now. Just ways to reach people in ways that are interesting, in ways that don't make them feel like, well, how am I gonna get this over to streaming? The experience is really the only thing I can deliver. Anyway, I'll see you next week.

More from this hub

Something wrong, or a video you want off this page? Write to wethem.xyz@gmail.com and it is fixed or taken down within 48 hours.