The One Question bounty closes Thursday 10 December.

Join in
We Them Media logo We Them Media Support us

Stablecoins & the Future of Digital Payments in Africa | Panel Session @Web3LagosCon 5.0

The picture loads from YouTube. The player loads only when you press Play. Turn on captions in the player if you need them.

Panelists at Web3 Lagos Conference debate stablecoin payments in Africa. They discuss why fintechs keep rebuilding the same liquidity systems, whether crypto solves the last mile, onchain foreign exchange, and hiding the technology from users. They also cover peer-to-peer trading, licensing rules that favour regulated institutions, tokenised Nigerian stocks, which blockchains lead in which regions, and the need for companies to merge and pool resources.

Not by We Them Media Channel: Web3Bridge. Published Monday 26 October 2026.

Titles are the owner’s. It plays from their channel.

Transcript

This transcript may contain errors. This video belongs to Web3Bridge. Letters mark each change of speaker.

These are the speakers’ own words. We have not checked their claims.

0:00 A: Hi everyone, good evening. Hope we've been having an amazing time with all of the amazing speakers that have come on stage to like share their knowledge with us today. So yeah, uh, this is a panel session that I really, really look forward to. I have these amazing panelists with me, huge names in the industry. Please, can we give them a round of applause, please? Thank you very much. Okay, uh, just to get right into it, uh, I think I'm going to start with, um, Timmy. You're the one right beside me, right? Uh, you gave a talk very recently, and I think your topic was, um, why is every fintech rebuilding the same stablecoin liquidity stack? Right? Something along that line, right? So what exactly are we all rebuilding, and why hasn't this become a shared infrastructure yet for all the stablecoin companies that we have coming out of this country?

1:03 B: Thank you. I, I think I'll come at it from a certain perspective. I think when the pie is bigger, then everyone can eat more. You get what I mean? So Every founder has really good optimism. Like, I think I can do this. I can take over the world. Right. And then when you start like that and you initially think you don't need the other person, and then when you start building, you're like, what have I gotten into? You know what I mean? And you see that payments is not as simple as just integrate this API. There's a lot that goes into it. And so but when we start thinking about the willingness to build shared infrastructure, that's where it begins. When you want to do that, then you can now see how this person does it like this, this person like this. And what we are ending up doing is we are building an ecosystem, extending the pie, the ocean, or the cake, or whatever you call it. And then we can have more avenues to create second-level derivatives of that lake or something we've created rather than still solving the base layer issues. Yeah. So that's what I think. So I just go on.

2:13 A: Thank you very much. That was amazing. So willingness to like build this shared infrastructure already, right? Also, just to quickly follow up on that, if I'm building like a remittance or cross-border payments product today, what part of stablecoin stack do you think I absolutely do not need to be building myself? Yes, I'm just following up on the previous question about shared infrastructure.

2:35 B: Ask it again.

2:36 A: Okay. So if I'm building a remittance or cross-border payments product today, what part of stablecoin stack should I absolutely not be building myself?

2:45 B: If you're building a remittance product, I don't think you have any business dealing with maybe banking rails. It is just remittance. There are people that are more localized because remittance means you're moving money from one corridor to another corridor. So you're not experiencing the other corridor. If you're originating in one direction, then you can leverage the deep network or the deep liquidity the other expert in that corridor already has. So that's where that protocol I was speaking about earlier. comes in that helps you leverage experts in the corridor you want to go into.

3:15 A: Um, thank you very much. All right, um, right after you, Sean. You're building HyperFX around the idea that stablecoins can become the FX settlement infrastructure, and you're using CNGN for the naira leg. What does putting FX fully on-chain actually solve that today's fintech FX and liquidity infrastructure doesn't solve yet?

3:38 C: Right. So I think on-chain FX solves 2 major problems. Number one is counterparty risk. A lot of the fintechs, what they or how they essentially operate is they have a lot of naira, like your, I don't know, Monica, your Spenda, your Breeds. They just hold a lot of naira in their bank accounts. And whenever people send them USDC, they release the naira to your accounts, right? And then eventually they end up with a lot of USDC and not a lot of naira. And now what they need to do is switch that USDC back into naira so they can continue to provide that service. And the way in which they do this is they engage OTC venues, right? So mostly on WhatsApp, these OTC traders help these fintechs to rebalance, as it were, or go between different currencies. Now, because it's on WhatsApp, you essentially have to then send them your USDC and then hope at some point they send you back your naira. So there's counterparty risk there as well. So on-chain FX, if you're, if you're doing this trade and you're, you know, switching USDC to CNGN on-chain, there is no counterparty risk because A smart contract essentially escrows your USDC while it waits for a liquidity provider to provide the liquidity that you're requesting. And if no one, you know, provides that liquidity within a set period of time- of course, this is a period of time that you have configured- you are eligible for a refund. So you get basically, you get your money back. So smart contracts and on-chain effects eliminates the risk. And I mean, we've seen this issue. And it's not theoretical. I mean, we all saw what happened with Plaud and the Zakutin company where they sent them over ₦8 billion hoping for USDC. And I think they only got like, I don't know, a few million dollars back. So this is counterparty risk in action, right? And honestly, I think the second thing that on-chain FX solves is liquidity aggregation and settlement times. So even on these OTC venues, they don't necessarily have all the liquidity, right? If I say, hey, give me like $3 million worth of stables, the guy is just going to go and talk to all his friends and then try to basically do that liquidity aggregation. And that takes time. Whereas if you come to an on-chain venue that already has multiple liquidity providers, this venue can then aggregate the liquidity across these providers. to ensure instant settlements. So rather than you waiting for this guy to aggregate the liquidity, that liquidity has already been pre-aggregated on-chain and it's just settled instantly across all the LPs. So these are the problems that I think on-chain FX solves. But even more so, it solves open access to liquidity. So today, if you're building a fintech, if you're building a remittance product and you need liquidity, You have to go on like KYB to someone who's going to then give you access to their APIs. KYB takes so long. Sometimes they might not even respond to your requests. Maybe they flag your liquidity. They say, ah, our compliance has said that this is broken somehow. We don't know where this came from. These are downtimes that your business faces. But with an on-chain protocol, you don't really have these issues. There's no KYB, of course, because it's fully on-chain, it's fully permissionless. You just take out of the liquidity pool whenever you like. And we don't really deal with the fiat leg as well. So that's why it's completely permissionless. So these are just some of the- I could go on forever, but these are just some of the, I think, problems that on-chain FX solves.

7:27 A: Yeah, thank you very much. And I hope our audience are listening to these amazing speakers. Jessica, I'm just going to come over there real quick. A lot of stablecoin conversations happen around from the perspective of crypto-native users, right? But much of your work has focused on financial inclusion. Are stablecoins genuinely solving financial inclusion problems in emerging markets, or are we sometimes just building better financial products for people who were already digitally connected?

8:00 D: Yeah, I think very good question, and my answer would have changed years from here. If you were asking me this question 6 years ago, I would have tell you, yes, 100%, crypto will solve a lot of problems. You don't need to do KYC, you don't need to do all of that. So anytime someone doesn't have any national ID, they could access actually any financial services, either this is, you know, saving, credit, or whatsoever. So that would solve it. Now that regulation have come into place, what does actually crypto solve that current model in Africa and especially in a region like Nigeria or even Kenya, where the quality of the solutions that are already available is there, right? I don't think crypto solves anything. If anything, they are solving, as I think the lady from Flutterwave mentioned, the middle layer. How do we move money cross-border? How do we make sure liquidity is available where it needs to be? But it doesn't solve the last mile. And I think we need to be very clear with that right now.

9:05 A: All right, thank you very much, Jessica. Um, right, uh, Bitbata sits at the point where crypto actually has to become usable money, right, at some point. From your own experience, where does the stablecoin payments become difficult today? Is it the parts where we get the money on chain or moving it, or the liquidity parts, or just getting local currency out on the other end? Where exactly do you think the problem, or like, is from making crypto to becoming like a usable money for an average person?

9:40 E: So we- there are several verticals, right? And to distill your question a little bit, let's look at some of those verticals. First and foremost, we need to look at currency payments, right? Crypto, stablecoins, They are instruments for settlement but not instruments for payment. It's not a legal tender. So first of all, the government or governments in countries have to first of all classify them as payment instruments. We have seen some countries in America, Southern Latin America, and they have tried to make Bitcoin a legal tender so you could go to the shop and buy with Bitcoin. But it's not so with the region where we exist, like in Nigeria. So generally, the license being issued here in Nigeria sees stablecoins and some of these digital assets as settlement instruments. So if we push forward from that perspective, we have a, we have a government that is forward-thinking in terms of crypto. It might still look a little bit fuzzy right now, but, um, what we're experiencing in Nigeria is what we're experiencing everywhere in the world. It's not like in America they've gotten their crypto act, the crypto bill at the Senate, they've gotten it right. They are still dibbling-dabbling, going back and forth and trying to get it fixed. The same thing also in Nigeria, the same thing across the world in a lot of countries. So we expect that Maybe sometime in future, the- our environment will be able to metamorphosize and the government will understand that this could also be used as a legal tender. Um, sure, it has some parts of it that might not expressly allow it to be used as a legal tender, but the government in its forward thinking thought about e-Naira and implemented. I wouldn't say Naira is a complete failure because for other stablecoins like CNGN, they have been powered by eNaira. But maybe you'll never really see that somewhere, but tokens like CNGN have been powered by eNaira. So we don't know, it's still too early in the space, so we don't know where things are going to head and how things are going to develop. But we know that there's a market here, there's users, there is problems that have been solved. This is an amazing technology, the stablecoin itself is one of the most primary, uh, proven use case of crypto and cryptocurrency in general. Now, the difficulty in this space, uh, all the, all the, all the, um, all the, the, the items you mentioned, right, the liquidity, the FX, all of them are different form of pinpoint, and they all exist. And I don't know which is more, right, but So we have seen- what we have seen from the market is that all of that exists, and, um, we'll continue to build innovative products to see how we make these things better. For me, in future, what I think is that the market is going to converge. Liquidity is going to converge because when the naira is moving on an electronic naira from bank to bank, let's say through NEBS and PABs and all those things, right, it has a reduced velocity as of when it is moving on-chain. If the naira is moving on the blockchain like a tokenized naira, it's faster, right? So we believe that liquidity is going to converge. When you, when you initiate a transaction on one platform, it might have gone through several other platforms that you don't even know because everything has been cascaded in the back end and the transactions end at the other end. and then you get your Bitcoin or you get your naira. So yeah, stuff like that.

13:35 A: Thank you very much for that amazing answer. Uh, Michael, uh, Nigeria is now one of the world's largest stablecoin markets, but I want to start with a very basic question, right? Are Nigerians actually adopting stablecoins or they're just simply adopting the dollar?

13:57 F: Are Nigerians adopting stablecoins or adopting the dollar?

14:01 A: Yes,

14:03 F: I think that question is pretty easy to answer. There are 2 different categories, right? Um, there are people interested in the dollar for reasons best known to them. One of those reasons could be as a way to you know, hedge, right? While there are other people who need stablecoins for practical use cases like settlements. The word settlement payments has been used a lot in this panel session so far. And when you look at the practicality of things, you know that majority of the people that are venturing into stablecoin use it to solve their daily problems, right? They use it on a daily basis. So be it receiving my salary as a freelancer or using it to settle my international trade. So I think adoption- I think Nigerians don't get enough credit when it comes to adoption of stablecoins because they just look at it from a- from one lens. right, are not looking at the bigger picture of how this has become a part of our daily lives. Right. So I think the answer is it is not solely to access the dollar, but people also use cryptocurrency stablecoins as part of their daily lives to solve real-life problems.

15:39 A: All right. Thank you very much. Just to quickly follow up on that, right, if you removed the dollar exposure and offered Nigerians exactly the same blockchain benefits through a naira stablecoin, specifically CNGN, right? Do you think the retail users would actually want it?

15:55 F: I don't see why not, because I mean, let's look at the value proposition. Does it, does it help you settle payments? Does it? Of course it does, right? Are you able to move the CNGN across blockchain platforms? Are you able to do that? Yes, you can. And let's just look at it as an alternative to the traditional payment system for now, right? Because if you've been very observant, you would notice that there are times where the banking rails are not so efficient. Now, this is not any beef against the banking industry or whatnot, because I- my experience also stemmed from banking. But this can be an alternative for people to settle payments faster, right? And you know, the, the whole idea of the blockchain, although I don't want to speak, is because the retail users do not care about the technology. But being able to see that, oh, I'm expecting inflow and I can see it somewhere Um, I'm expecting- I can see it somewhere on chain. It's actually quite amazing. So I think there are a lot of use cases for, for stablecoin, a naira stablecoin, and not necessarily a USDT.

17:25 A: Thank you very much, Michael. Uh, Sean, one of the claims behind PiFX is that stablecoin settlements can reduce the need for fintechs to maintain pre-funded liquidity across different markets, right? How does that work in practice? Somebody ultimately has to provide the naira, right? Dollars or cedis somewhere. So does the stablecoin infrastructure eliminate the liquidity problem, or it just simply reorganizes it?

17:54 C: I think you already answered it, and it's definitely a reorganization of how liquidity is layered. So previously, the fintechs, they held their own float and then they rebalance with the professional LPs who are sitting behind, you know, OTC desks. In that architecture, the OTC desks are at the bottom, and then there's a buffer, which is the fintech liquidity. But what OnchainFX does is it removes them from the bottom and then places them directly in front of their users. So now the fintechs don't need to hold their own floats. They can just tap directly. They can just route directly to the LPs' liquidity. And basically, maybe they even add a little bit of a haircut. You know, they add their own spread and they make money from selling what they are really buying at wholesale to their retail users at retail prices. So this is- yeah, this is how I think on-chain FX reorganizes that architecture. But even more so, on-chain FX is a part of a new kind of system. So previously in cross-border flows, if you wanted to receive payments from a new country or a new jurisdiction, you have to like partner with PSSPs. PSSPs will ask you for your license. That's a whole new regulatory nightmare. In the alternative, in a parallel timeline where we have stablecoins, all you do is you work with the stablecoin issuer. They receive payments on your behalf. they mint those payments as a stablecoin that you can control in your wallet. And then you can then use on-chain FX to switch between different stablecoins. And if you need to settle, you settle out to the stablecoin issuer and then they pay out to whoever you want to pay out to.

19:42 A: All right. Thank you very much. Chibi, earlier when Etienne was talking, he mentioned something around the fact that stablecoin right now is just like a means of settlement. It's not like a real legal tender, right? And right now we've gotten very good at moving stablecoins globally in seconds, but someone still has to deliver the naira because people still need to pay their local market woman, right? Is the blockchain now the easy part and local settlements the actual hard problem?

20:14 B: Yeah, I, I think that, um, The local part is a hard problem because it's always been- it's not like it's not like a new thing, right? And to be fair, I'm from Nigeria, as you know, and banking infrastructure is really top-notch when it comes to like the leaves, what you're doing with NIPSS and the likes. And so that's good. But just like my co-panelists have spoken over the minutes we've been here, they've been talking about floats, they've been talking about settlement. All those words, they are real problems. We've not spoken about regulation. We've not spoken about- there's a lot of things we haven't spoken about because of time, but those are real problems. Right. And the blockchain for me, because I'm a blockchain engineer, so it's very simple to say that part is more- I wouldn't say it's easy, but it's more predictable. It's math. The proof is done. But the off-chain side, the last mile from stablecoin to fiat, that's where what we're trying to do with PayQuest. Because why, why I see that as very difficult, because there's no way for you to prove- I want everything to be on-chain, but there's no way to really prove that an off-chain payment actually happened. You sent money to someone, how do you know? How do you put that on blockchain? How do you put that proof there to make that more easy? So I think that that's really a hard problem that is going to take a while. And we're on that path with PayQuest pushing and seeing how you can make that provable. And so it makes it easy for anyone building on-chain to go from stablecoin to fiat and fiat to stablecoin without giving up the ethos of the blockchain, if you get what I mean. And another thing is, I think from my years working with, um, KidsCoin, I- for 3 years, I, I learned that everything in the world, every problem in the world is a coordination failure. Every problem, right? You're a guy, you have 3 girlfriends, and they all show up at your door to burn down, down your house. That's a coordination failure. You get what I mean? You've been there. You're, you're, you're, you're a, you're a husband, you have a wife, and she says, you're not giving me time because of your work, because of this and that. That's a coordination failure. So when we begin to think about stablecoins, we begin to think, I see it as a coordination problem. So I start thinking, how can we better coordinate the parties to ensure that they work in a way that doesn't cause that problem like my brother there is experiencing?

22:56 A: Thank you very much. That was amazing. So I'm just going to like follow up on that real quick. I'm talking about the last mile. So what prevents that last mile from becoming as permissionless and composable as the blockchain side?

23:11 B: Yeah, I, I do not think it's ever going to be as permissionless. Now I know it's weird, I say we're building this permissionless stablecoin to fiat, but I, I don't think it's going to ever be completely- be as permissionless as the blockchain to go from stablecoin to fiat. But I think you don't have to solve every problem, you just have to ensure you're close enough to the solution that the exemption in the rule is just very tiny. Like get the approximation to be very, very close that it works for a lot of use cases and a lot of people. And then it doesn't look like a problem anymore. You get what I mean? I don't think there's anyone that has a perfect, let's say, job or a perfect relationship or all that kind of stuff. But if you can get as close to perfect as you can get, that's good. So I think that can we put proofs up? On-chain? Yes. Do we have APIs now? You can have RSA signatures, you can do ZK stuff. Yes. Are there going to be some issues like chargebacks? How do you handle chargebacks? How do you handle all that? We don't have to solve everything, but just get as close as possible to make this usable for a lot of the blockchain protocols. And that works for me.

24:20 A: Thank you very much, Chibi. That was amazing. Jessica, you're building products where someone can hold value in dollars but spend locally without constantly thinking about FX blockchain, right? Is that what mainstream stablecoin adoption ultimately looks like, where the stablecoin disappears completely from the user experience?

24:42 D: Can you maybe repeat the beginning of the question? Sorry, I couldn't-

24:47 A: Sure.

24:47 D: The beginning.

24:48 A: Okay. So you're building products where someone can hold value in dollars but spend locally without constantly thinking about FX or blockchain. So I'm asking now, is that what mainstream stablecoin adoption ultimately looks like, where the stablecoin disappears completely from the user experience?

25:05 D: Yes, I'm not a big fan of having, you know, stablecoin crypto as a whole being front and center. I think we touched base a lot on this today, but it's a technology. I don't know most of the technology behind the tools I'm using on a daily basis. I do not need to know this is stablecoin, a blockchain, whatever. But also, I think we tend to have this idea that people want stablecoin. People don't want stablecoin, they want easy payment. When I'm in Kenya, I don't want to have a Kenya shilling on chain so I can send to my friend in Nigeria. I want to have Kenya shillings in my mobile money so I can pay a merchant. So I think here is we, we advance in the technology, we have more stablecoin, we have more local stablecoin is great. But again, the, the, the end goal is still as a settlement. How do we move from one currency to another is not something that user will want in their head. And I think also it's just, you know, putting this front and center to user creates a lot of friction. Technology has advanced again, but how do you explain gas fees? So how do you explain chain? How do you abstract all of this? You don't want them to be thinking about this. So I think, yeah, conversation should not be about how do we make crypto a better user experience. It's just how do we abstract it fully? Yeah.

26:26 A: Thank you very much. So viewers in the room, you've heard it. You should make you should give your users better experience by making the stablecoin disappear completely. Right. Excuse me. P2P has become one of the primary ways Nigerians have accessed stablecoins when formal banking channels became difficult. As regulations become clearer and institutional rules improve, do you think P2P remains a major part of Nigerian stablecoin economy 5 years from now?

27:03 E: You are talking about regulation too much. It looks like I'm a representative of the government. Please don't mind this. So, um, I can tell you what it is right now, and I can also tell you what it is in 5 years' time. P2P is very, um, essential. When the whole crypto thing started, it was based on P2P. P2P means that I can send you money without having to use a centralized entity. like let's say central bank. All the transactions you make from OPay to Zenith to whatever, right, goes through, um, Zenith Bank. It goes through central bank directly and indirectly. So, but that, that was pushed a little bit further to P2P transactions, P2P trading. It's like I have fiat and you have Bitcoin. I, I meet you somewhere, I meet you in the kiosks. Maybe you run a kiosk like a malam shop. That was what it used to be, like 2010, 2011. That was where the idea of P2P came up. Some, some people thought about, okay, how do we digitize this? How do we put this on the platform? Then we started seeing early platforms that built P2P systems, like the likes of Paxful and all those kind of stuff. So I called my co-founders on the 23rd of December 2023, and I told them that the CBN circular means that P2P is dead. Right, so I can tell you categorically right now P2P is dead, but it might not be completely dead. We might have to go back to P2P. It depends on how things turn out. That's why I say things are still very early. We don't know how the future is going to look like. But what we know is that there's a problem, there's a solution, there's a technology, and all these things exist, right? For example, um, some recent regulation or proposed regulations by the regulators ranging from NRS to SEC to CBN might encourage people to go back to the P2P face of things as it used to be. How can you tell me to pay 1.5% stamp duty on crypto? So sometimes in crypto, in the- in, in the- like our friend said, in the OTC space, right, it might- we might see that Nigeria processed over $91 billion in crypto transactions, but I can categorically tell you that maybe 3/4 of that money was just recycled transactions. So Party A wants to pay Party B, Party A talks to Party Z and Party Y, so they recycle trade before Party A now pays Party B, right? But on-chain, when you count those transactions, it amounts to the $91 billion, right? So imagine at each of those points you are paying 1%. So it's, it's a lot of difficulty. That people, users don't want to. I, as an operator operating an exchange, we are licensed by SEC. If NRS tells me to put up the 1.5% stamp duty, I'm going to definitely put it up because I don't want to be in DSS custody, right? So, um, but that does not encourage the market. So the markets can go back to P2P market, right? So we expect that the regulators- currently the regulators are looking like they are friendly. We expect that they continue being friendly. They can join us to understand the markets and not give room for underground transactions to go on. Right. So that all this could be regulated and we could see what's going on because this affects Nigeria as a country. You know, organizations like FATF, organizations like- there are several organizations that make sure Nigeria is compliant on the global level. And crypto is a critical part of it. These are- this- if these things are not being taken care of, foreign direct investment might not come in, foreign direct portfolios might not be opened up. This affects the economy in general because the financial world, it's, it's, it's a globe, right? It operates as a full, as a full circle. Right. So Treasury bills, the government might not be able to meet up and several other things. But this is an opportunity for us to even be able to go several x on what we meet up in terms of Treasury bills. Right now, the central bank and the Ministry of Finance could put up that they want to sell bonds worth ₦3 trillion and they get that thing being filled very fast. But what if the central bank will say we want to raise 30 trillion naira, right? If, if those bonds have been tokenized, if someone selling a kiosk in Japan can buy into treasury bills or bonds in Nigeria because it's a digital asset being sold on an exchange, right? So those are avenues that we could open up. But when you begin to say, okay, let's charge 1.5% treasury bills, those things can- 1.5% stamp duties, right? Those things cannot open up foreign money cannot flow into the system, and even the local money which is already domiciled will go underground, right? So like I said, what is it going to look in the next 5 years? If regulation go well, P2P will completely disappear because right now it is disappearing, right? So yeah, thank you.

32:17 A: Thank you very much. Um, very briefly, I would like you to follow up on that. You, as someone who is building an on-chain Do you agree with what Etienne has just said?

32:26 C: Yeah, I think, um, P2P is definitely not going away, but it will change the form in which it exists. P2P is not very different from what currently exists on-chain, like Uniswap. Like, Uniswap is, you know, one of the most successful crypto protocols I think they've processed like $4 trillion or more in transaction volume. And it is P2P, right? Like people go on a pool and they provide liquidity and other people, when they swap on that pool, they're really taking liquidity from the people who have provided liquidity on that pool. So I think the reason why people haven't adopted Uniswap locally, for instance, is just because you know, there's not been a stablecoin for the naira. Let's not forget CNGN was just launched last year, so it's still very, very early. And I think in 5 years we should definitely see CNGN at at least 10% of the naira money supply. And of course, this is just a very, in my opinion, optimistic prediction. I think it will likely be more. Because just beyond the fact that, of course, you can use it for FX and stablecoin swaps, blockchains are more reliable than NIBS and the Nigerian banking system where if you want to move billions of dollars or billions of naira, you basically have to sign forms and compliance checks and all these different things. And it's just unnecessary. So those are the 2 reasons why I think definitely CNGN will reach those levels of supply. but also P2P will move on-chain where it's less problematic and it's more seamless for everyone involved.

34:20 A: Thank you very much. So this next question is actually going to be like an open floor question. I think it's the right time to introduce it because again, the other time mentioned a lot of stuff about regulation, right? About 10 days before this conversation, the Nigerian SEC published proposed rules creating a much broader framework for digital assets, including stablecoins. Foreign-issued stablecoins would need recognition within regulated activities while issuers face regulated- while issuers face reserved redemption and liquidity requirements. From where each of you sits, what's one thing that you think the regulators get right and one thing you're worried that they might get wrong?

35:03 D: Yeah, I think I just want to get this one for this. I would- I read actually the one from the SEC, 85 pages. I think that was long. It's very clear to me that they understood very well that stablecoin is not, again, a means of payment, but settlement. There was one that pretty much struck me was 80% of the assets from a customer that you custody as a company, an infrastructure, needs to be in cold storage. If you are a payment company, keeping 80% of customer assets in cold storage is not possible. Like, nobody will make payment orchestration with cold storage. So I think that's one. The second, I think it's very clear based on the requirements that they are pushing for already regulated institutions to enter that licensing rather than startups. We went through the process. at PowerPay, there is 300 questions to just join the sandbox. The amount of documents you need to provide, nobody at a startup level can provide this. So I think it's just very clear those who are already regulated, that have licenses and use it for settlement, not in front of retail. I would say that's my take at least.

36:25 A: Thank you very much, Jessica. Do I have anyone who wants Okay.

36:29 E: So for me, one of the things they get wrong- let me start from there because I think that's where it's spinning me, right? One of the things they get wrong is that the regulators, the regulators from NFIU to EFCC to CBN to SEC to NRS, name all of them, right down to the Senate, right, committees in capital market and finance. They tend to always forget that crypto has dual personality, dual function. It exists as a payment instrument and it also exists as an- it has an exchange function. So by the time you are telling me to pay some certain type of tax on it, or I should use it in a certain way, it begins to limit what the digital asset could do in itself. Um, if you tell me to operate purely as an exchange, maybe like what is similar to Nigerian Stock Exchange- we are not a stock exchange, this is a crypto exchange. Once you touch the Bitcoin, you can make payments and you can also exchange with it. So don't try to limit what I can do with it. Rather, um, allow me to be more innovative, right? The government makes money, I make money, everybody makes money, we employ people. people and the economy becomes better. So what do they do well? Um, one of the things they do well is that I think they wanting to regulate the space. Even I, I'm not talking about the intent, then wanting to do that is a good one. If you look throughout all the metrics in finance ranging from capital market to financial markets and all that, it's always been the institutions driving the volumes. And I, I bet you we won't be able to do those volumes if regulation doesn't come in, right? We look at, um, people like MoneyPoint transacting over $25 billion monthly, right? They won't be able to do that if they are not licensed as a bank. So imagine if MoneyPoint as a single entity processes that amount of money. Imagine what can happen in crypto because the velocity on crypto is faster than the naira in the bank accounts, right? So it's- I think Nigeria growing from 91.26 billion annually, I think that is going to be a volume of just one institution, right? One exchange, maybe Quidax, maybe Bitbata, maybe Flutterwave. Like, so imagine what it could be, right? So, so we are happy they are trying to put some structure in the space, but we are not happy the way they are trying to put the structure. And, um, Thankfully, they are friendly, and we will continue to see how we help them put that structure the right way.

39:22 A: Thank you very much. Michael, you want to say something?

39:24 F: Oh yeah, I'm just going to piggyback off what both people have said. So I'll start with what the regulation has done right, or what the regulators have done right. So the mere fact that they recognize that the space is a big part of the Nigerian financial markets and it needs to be regulated, um, it's a good one. It has also given institutional players the confidence to start talking about these things publicly because we see the likes of Flutterwave announcing partnerships with um, crypto companies, right? So I think it has given institutional players that confidence to want to, you know, engage with us. And in the coming weeks or months, because now the CBN is now involved, so we would expect that the traditional banks would start also engaging with crypto. The impact on retail users, our, our older generations, our parents, would now be the fact that, oh, this crypto that they've always heard about in a negative light, if the banks are now engaging with this company, it means it's not as bad as we thought it was, or the first impression we got about it is not actually what it is. So we might as well ask more questions and get into it, bringing our old money into it to see what we can do with it. So I think that part they've gotten right. Now, to Essien's point on what they would need to improve on or look at to ensure that they don't make mistakes I always focus my opinions on the end users, right? I don't want people to start looking at crypto as, oh, the government just wants to use this thing to make- generate income, right? So I'm going to stay clear, right? So I think they should look at their policies to ensure that coming into the space should be with the idea of coming to protect customers, coming to make it a safe space for them to, to engage in financial activities, protect customers, ensure that the players have the right guardrails, the right frameworks to ensure that they are operating sustainably and not just focusing on how much they can benefit from it. I think that is one aspect they need to look at and do better. Yeah.

42:24 A: Thank you very much. I'm sure the other speakers would like to say something, but before you go, Sean, I'd just like to add like a follow-up question to your thoughts so you can answer at once, right? If compliance becomes expensive enough that only large companies can participate, have we regulated risks Or have we just simply regulated startups out of the market?

42:48 C: I'm going to answer that, but before I answer, I want to comment on what specifically regulators are doing wrong. I don't really have any positive comments for them, unfortunately.

43:01 A: I know we're streaming this. I hope our regulators are listening, please.

43:04 C: And this is- this even goes beyond Nigeria, right? Because, um, in the US The Clarity Act is at the center of fighting for a new kind of freedom for human beings all over the world. So just to quickly, you know, explain what the Clarity Act is. The Clarity Act wants to make provisions for DeFi protocols to function outside of any kind of regulatory purview. And it's not because of, oh, they want to allow criminals or whatever. It's primarily because banks and regulated platforms have been used to essentially disenfranchise people and discriminate people and cut off financial services. And that's why blockchains exist, right? That's why they've been so successful. And so if we try to reintroduce regulation just so we can do what we've done all over again, it becomes highly problematic. No one's going to follow it. And that's why we now start to see P2P markets come up and people innovate around the regulation. So I think regulators home and abroad need to start to understand that blockchains are not just a technology, but they are also a fight for new financial freedoms that the banks, that the regulated platforms have withheld from everyday people. Right now, back to your question about, you know, if all these capital requirements come into play, then what happens to startups? Let's not mince words. The financial space is full of players who essentially build regulations around their business. This is the banking model, and this is the, you know, exchange model. That's why you have to have a license to be an exchange. That's because the first people that became exchanges, they just built a, you know, wall around their business, and they called it capital requirements, and they called it, you know, consumer protection. And so this is why I think blockchains exist, is because these applications that you can build in, in the traditional financial realm are also possible on the blockchain. There's really nothing you want to build in the traditional finance space and infrastructure that you can't build on the blockchain. And I can tell you right now, a good example for this is Nigerian stocks. How many people actually know how to buy Nigerian stocks? You know, this is because of the ridiculous amount of regulatory moats that have been built around the NGX and the brokers. And now what's happening, startups like Gift Equity, they're going to tokenize these stocks and then make them available to everyone. This just would not be possible. You can see how this is not possible on the traditional financial rails, but blockchains are making this possible. So That's just my own opinion, is that the regulated people, they will try to build, you know, wall around their business, but they will inevitably be disrupted by permissionless rails.

46:05 A: Thank you very much. Uh, back to you, Jessica. We often talk about Africa as though it's one payments market. From building across different African markets, how different are the actual stablecoin problems in Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, and somewhere else outside of Africa?

46:27 D: Yeah, I mean, question is good. It goes back to what we discussed earlier on. The hardest part is the last mile, right? So stablecoin, very, I would say, easy in Nigeria. You have local stablecoins. So going from USD to naira, very easy to be embedded in day-to-day and removing this complexity in terms of user experience. You go to Kenya, the complexity is totally, totally different here. Even if we had local stablecoin, there is different layer. It's not only moving internationally, it's moving money to a bank and from the bank to the mobile money operator. And this just movement of money between a bank to a mobile money operator can take up to 5 days. If you go to Cameroon, it can take 15 days. So it's like stablecoins here are not going to solve this type of issue. So I would say when the beauty of it is you have one layer that is similar for all the markets, but every single market, regardless of if you operate East Africa or West Africa, is different. You have different operators, different mobile money, different banks, and you need to adapt to that. So there is not, I would say, one model fits all regardless of technology. that you're using.

47:44 A: Thank you very much. Chibi, PayCryse recently crossed about $5 million in payment volume, and you've said the growth curve is beginning to bend. What changed? Are you seeing a fundamental change in stablecoin payment demand, or is infrastructure finally becoming good enough for businesses to use?

48:03 B: Um, did I post that? Okay. Yeah, it's really okay. I think from my perspective, Paycrest functioning as payment infrastructure, payment protocol, we experienced a sort of growth in demand last year. And then there was protocol reliability issues based on what I said, coordination failure. So reliability fell down from like 98% to like, I think the lowest was probably 76% success rate. That was a real tank. And then- but something interesting happened. Demand didn't cease. It just felt like it waited. You know what I mean? So it waited for us to recalibrate. And as I told you, it's a coordination failure. So we sat, drew everything back on the map, fixed that issue, and now we've been back up for months now at 90, over 95%. I- what I showed, 196.7, and then demand just flows again. So I don't think there's a stablecoin demand issue because we need it for merchant settlement, as I said, for hedging against inflation, whatever reason. These days I've been using stablecoins, I've been experimenting with on-chain stocks, and it's very liberating to just plug your stocks, your MCP, or just do some sort of experiments, and which is not possible traditionally. So I think when I say the curve is bending, not necessarily like that the demand stops coming, is the fact that I, I noticed that when the payment infrastructure is reliable and that reliability is sustained, then you just notice that people that are moving or companies routing 50K begin to say, okay, 100K, okay, 1 million, you get what I mean? So it just keeps going up like that, but you have to ensure- so before I was optimizing for, let's just grow this volume or grow the volume. That's not it. I noticed reliability is there, and that then gives you the distribution. You know, it's more like you just wait it out. You're still doing work, but like, for the most part, you know.

50:16 A: Um, thank you very much, Chibi. Uh, Sean, Again, stablecoin liquidity today is fragmented across Ethereum, Tron, Base, Solana, and other networks. As someone who has worked on interoperability yourself, right, from an interoperability perspective, how big a problem is that fragmentation for stablecoins becoming serious payment infrastructure?

50:41 C: It's a huge problem, um, because As you can understand, a different stablecoin on a different network is not really fungible unless there is interoperability infrastructure like a bridge that makes that happen. But at the same time, look, there's already a lot of bridges. Bridges are not a problem. I think for me, the thing that I'm more worried about is the security of these bridges. And I'm not going to sit here and wax philosophical about how HyperBridge is the most secure and everything. You know, we've had our lessons in mainnet, but I think we're not just the only ones, right? Even LayerZero had a more expensive lesson than us, even Across, even Near in 10. So literally every bridge in production today has had a security incident. But I think the question is that the security- what's the nature of the security incidents and are these security incidents fixable? For HyperBridge, you know, we had a software bug. This bug has been fixed. We're properly back online and we're processing transactions. The way in which we see bridges being used in the future is not necessarily because you want to copy one asset from one network and then paste it on a different network. We think people will want to move between different representations of assets across different networks. I'll give you an example. On HyperFX today, people are swapping USDT on BNB Chain to CNGN on Base, which is a very interesting route. I never- we never predicted it. But when you bring all these networks together and you let people move between them independently, these routes start to emerge and you start to see, oh, these are interesting ways in which people are using it. Mind you, there's no CNGN liquidity on BNB Chain. Right? So a bridge is the only way in which that swap could have existed. So yeah, I think bridges are going to be very important for swapping, and I think they're also going to be very important for stablecoin flows and payments.

52:52 A: All right. Just follow up on that quickly because you have experiences across bridges, right? Does the future have one dominant stablecoin network, or should the user and even the fintech be completely unaware of which chain settlement happens on?

53:07 C: So there's, there's a movement right now, especially in the DeFi space, where it's like, um, people should not really care where their assets live and, you know, where they want to eventually get to. Like in my case, right, the people who are on BNB chain, technically they just want naira, you know. They didn't really- they shouldn't really care that, oh, you have to swap it to CNGN on Base first, and then when you have the CNGN someone can then off-ramp it for you. I think they just want to eventually arrive at some goal. And so fintech apps, wallets, they, they're trying their best to essentially remove all that complexity and just make the user experience much more simpler. But I don't think that there's going to be any single dominant stablecoin network. And we can already look at what's happening today. You know, Ethereum was the first But a lot of people are eating Ethereum's lunch. You know, Tron is there now. BNB Chain is up there. Solana, as much as I hate it, um, you know, there's, there's a lot of different networks. Polygon, you know, and they have all found their niches. Tron is huge in Asia. Same with BNB Chain. Polygon is huge in Latin America. Uh, Base is huge, and Solana and Base are huge in the US. So, you know, at the end of the day, it's human beings that are building these networks, and these human beings have their own spheres of influence. And I think maybe one day we'll definitely see a huge blockchain that is, you know, developed by Africans be more adopted in Africa. That would be my dream.

54:40 A: I love that. All right, thank you very much. So as I'm coming to the end of this, um, panel, I'm just going to like, um, end with one question to challenge the premise of the entire panelists, right? So, uh, if stablecoins are cheaper, because we've heard from everything that we've all said today about how amazing stablecoin is and how easier it makes settlements, right? So if, if stablecoins, uh, generally, uh, easier, easier, it's cheaper, it's faster, and it's programmable, it's available 24/7, right? Why aren't most Africans using them for everyday payments already? So

55:24 D: I can answer this quick. Not the same currency. And again, I live in Paris, right? So I use euro. What is the point for me to pay in USD, for example? So I need to think about the FX rates in my head before I buy something because I will buy in stablecoin using USD and my bank will take in euro. So it just doesn't make sense from a user perspective. People want to pay. They don't want to have to think about FX, the currency. Am I going to have less or more? What is today's rate? And so on. So just as simple as that. Thank

56:00 E: you. There was a conference I spoke at sometime in Landmark. So there were 2 things I said. One of it is education. The other of it is user experience. And that part of the user experience we have discussed about it on this panel. So for stablecoins to become more usable, reduce the friction and all those kind of things related to its issues and its challenges and barriers, I think one of the two things that we need to do is to improve the experience and also improve the education. Right. A lot of people feel like crypto is a scam. That's one vertical. Some people also feel like it's a little bit too much. By the time you are depositing on BNB and you are withdrawing on Base and you have to pay gas fee, they're like, what the hell is gas fee and all that, right? So if, if we could choose some other technologies including wallet abstraction and transaction atomicity and all those principles, right? We're able to distill what the experience is and be able to educate people that, okay, this is a different kind of money, this, this is, this is faster and this is better, right? Then I think that will make it easier for everyone. Yeah, thank you.

57:28 A: Joshua, if you want to say something, fine.

57:35 F: Okay, so I think my response is more aligned to what she said earlier. I think it's a currency problem. In the whole of Europe, they have one currency that is recognized, which is the euro. While in Africa- your question was specifically to Nigeria? Yeah,

57:59 A: Nigeria specifically.

58:00 F: Nigeria. Oh, I thought you mentioned Africa. Because-

58:03 A: yes, I'm sorry, it's African.

58:05 F: Okay, I mean, if it's Africa, then it makes it clearer. I think we've gotten to a point where we need a unified currency for the whole of Africa for us to be able to connect with each other and trade with each other appropriately. Why do I have to- why do I have to convert naira to USD before I trade with someone in Benin, right? So I think we've gotten to a point where- and I know this conversation has already been had, people are talking about it already, but we've not really seen any material movements around it. So we've gotten to a point where we need a unified African currency That's where I think- that's where the conversation should be at right now.

59:01 A: All right, thank you very much.

59:03 B: Yeah, not to take away from what they've said, I don't go there asking why it's not being used or people don't use maybe stablecoins today. I, I think a lot of persons say, oh, there's a lot of on-ramp, off-ramp platforms, you need to build something else. And not just- I mean, platforms, applications and all, everyone is building something. And if I ask this room how many persons have used stablecoins, I think a lot of people will say they have. Yes, I agree, the market woman will definitely not use it. But again, I'm a big believer in don't solve- like, solve the base problems quickly so we can move on from rudimentary things and solve that derivative. That's something I've seen in our ecosystem culture, or just generally among we builders is the fact that if you're building an application and the number of users you can serve, your max is maybe you can serve 50K users and I can serve capacity to 700K users with proper float and the likes. Why don't we collaborate and merge, right? If we merge, then we can have synergy and probably do more because the way money is structured, you can't expect the powerful and rich people to give up their wealth to you. That doesn't happen anywhere. I, I think- I don't know how I'd behave in that place, but I think it doesn't happen anywhere. So the best you can do, instead of getting angry at, oh, some places don't want us in- the same thing about the licensing conversation- why don't you collaborate? If you say we have- again, I'm not talking about whether it's right or wrong, But let's say the capital requirements is $200 million and you don't have it. 4 of us would have it. We come together, build one company, put in our liquidity or whatever you think. You get that license, 5 companies as one. And then what do you do? You compete. You have to come up a bit to compete. But no, what we would rather think is This, this, this is not working for me. And then your company runs for 2 years or 3 years and it dies out. We can't reach much people like that if you don't merge. If there's no merger, there's no acquisition. The incubator will be just a random statement to them. The truth is, I don't think they're interested in acquiring a lot of- except you're aligning strongly with their thesis of vertical. So if you're offended enough, by- you want to change something, pull together. There's a favorite poet of mine that said this sentence in a poem. He said, be careful not to demonize your oppressors. When I mean oppressors, it's a metaphor for opposition, right? Be careful not to demonize your oppressors lest you become just like them. You know what I mean? So because when you're there, you do the same thing, right? There are some persons that have said something very angry about certain rules And I'm like, if a governor were to call you to his room and you were very offended that he was doing- ruling your state in a very sad way, and he says, bro, come sit with me, I think 80% of people would be like, ah, boss. You get what I mean? You get what I mean? And then so not everybody would- people, because you don't just- Yes. So yeah, so I think we're not reaching more persons because we're not consolidating enough. We're not measuring enough. There's not much acquisitions. We're not pooling resources enough. So you're powerful enough to sit at the table and then move the needle properly.

62:38 A: Thank you very much. That was amazing. And I think this finally brings us to the end of this panel session.

More from this hub

Something wrong, or a video you want off this page? Write to wethem.xyz@gmail.com and it is fixed or taken down within 48 hours.